Australia’s mining industry has long been a cornerstone of the national economy, driving significant economic growth and providing thousands of jobs. However, as the global landscape of mining evolves, Australian miners are increasingly looking beyond their borders for new opportunities. Setting up operations in another country presents both challenges and opportunities for these firms. One recent example is BHP’s interest in expanding its footprint in Indonesia, particularly in the nickel industry, in light of developments in Western Australia (WA).
This article explores the potential need for an Australian mining company to invest in a foreign base, the benefits and risks associated with such a move, and the specific case of BHP in Indonesia.
Why Australian Mining Companies are Expanding Overseas
Australia is rich in natural resources, and its mining industry has been a global leader for decades. However, there are some reasons why Australian mining companies might consider setting up operations in other countries.
Resource Depletion
As Australia’s most accessible mineral resources are gradually depleted, mining companies may need to look overseas to maintain production levels. This is particularly relevant for companies involved in extracting minerals that are essential for emerging technologies, such as nickel, which is crucial for electric vehicle batteries.
Market Diversification
Expanding into new markets allows companies to diversify their revenue streams and reduce their dependence on the Australian market. This can be particularly important in times of economic uncertainty or when domestic regulations tighten, making it more difficult to operate profitably in Australia.
Access to New Resources
Certain minerals may be more abundant or easier to extract in other countries. For example, Indonesia has vast reserves of nickel, making it an attractive destination for Australian companies looking to secure a stable supply of this critical resource.
Strategic Partnerships
Setting up operations in another country can facilitate strategic partnerships with local firms and governments. These partnerships can provide Australian companies with valuable insights into the local market, help navigate regulatory challenges, and potentially lead to new business opportunities.
Responding to Regulatory Changes
Regulatory environments in Australia, particularly in WA, can sometimes become restrictive, pushing companies to explore friendlier jurisdictions. Expanding operations overseas can be a strategic response to these changes, allowing firms to continue their growth trajectory without being hampered by domestic regulations.
Challenges of Expanding Mining Operations Overseas
While there are clear advantages to setting up shop in another country, there are also significant hurdles.
Regulatory and Legal Compliance
Operating in a foreign country requires compliance with local laws and regulations, which can be complex and vary significantly from those in Australia. Companies must invest time and resources in understanding these regulations and ensuring that their operations are fully compliant.
Political and Economic Risks
The political and economic stability of the host country is a critical factor. Unstable governments, sudden changes in policies, or economic downturns can pose significant risks to overseas operations. Companies need to conduct thorough risk assessments and develop strategies to mitigate these risks.
Cultural Differences
Understanding and adapting to cultural differences is essential when setting up operations in a new country. This includes not only language barriers but also differences in business practices, labour relations, and community expectations. Failing to navigate these cultural differences can lead to misunderstandings and operational inefficiencies.
Infrastructure and Logistics
The availability and quality of infrastructure in the host country can impact the success of a mining operation. Companies need to assess the state of local infrastructure, including transportation, energy supply, and communications, and be prepared to invest in upgrading these facilities if necessary.
Environmental and Social Considerations
Mining companies must also consider the environmental impact of their operations and the social responsibilities they have towards local communities. This includes adhering to environmental regulations, ensuring sustainable practices, and engaging with local stakeholders to address their concerns and expectations.
BHP Sets Sights on Indonesia
One of the most notable examples of an Australian mining company looking to set up operations overseas is BHP’s interest in Indonesia, particularly in the nickel industry. This move comes at a time when Western Australia, a key hub for BHP’s operations, is facing regulatory changes that could impact the company’s profitability and long-term strategy.
BHP announced in its EOFY24 report that the company’s nickel arm had underlying losses of $450 million. At the same time, the company decided to suspend all nickel operations in Australia, with a gradual phasedown from July to December 2024. The master plan will put the West Musgrave development project on hold, and suspend all work at the Kwinana nickel refinery, the mines in Mount Keith and Leinster, and the nickel smelter in Kalgoorlie. The plan is to restructure the local nickel mining operation to support the battery and EV sector.
The objective is to reactivate everything after an operational review in February 2027. Approximately $450m will be allotted every year from BHP’s budget to finance the restart.
However, BHP’s decision might exact a price on the labour front. As many as 1,600 jobs in the BHP nickel division are up in the air but around 400 front-line staff are being eyed to be back in action with the restart. The other affected staff will be made redundant or reassigned to BHP’s other divisions. BHP will also set up a $20m support fund for communities that may be affected by the suspension, including those in the Ngaanyatjarra, Tjiwarl, and Wiluna people’s land.
Indonesia Nickel Mining Association secretary-general Meidy Katrin Lengkey revealed in July 2024 that the Indonesian government had spent several months talking to BHP about the company’s plans.
Why is Indonesia an attractive destination for BHP?
Abundant Nickel Reserves
Indonesia is home to some of the world’s largest nickel reserves, making it a critical player in the global supply chain for electric vehicle batteries. The problem was a glut of nickel in the international metal markets, with prices going down from over US$25,000 per tonne in 2022 to barely US$16,700 by July 2024. By investing in Indonesia, BHP can secure a stable supply of nickel, which is essential for meeting the growing demand for electric vehicles.
Favourable Investment Climate
The Indonesian government has been actively encouraging foreign investment in its mining sector, offering incentives such as tax concessions and simplified regulatory processes. This makes Indonesia an appealing option for BHP as it looks to expand its operations. Outgoing Indonesian President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo’s decision to ban the local nickel industry from export operations gave China an opening to invest in the Southeast Asian country.
Strategic Location
Indonesia’s proximity to major markets in Asia, particularly China, offers significant logistical advantages. By setting up operations in Indonesia, BHP can reduce transportation costs and improve access to these key markets.
Partnership Opportunities
BHP’s move into Indonesia could also facilitate partnerships with local mining companies and government agencies. These partnerships could provide BHP with valuable insights into the local market and help navigate the regulatory landscape.
Challenges
However, BHP’s potential investment in Indonesia also comes with its own set of challenges.
Regulatory Uncertainty
While Jakarta has been encouraging foreign investment, the regulatory environment can still be unpredictable. Sudden changes in mining regulations or tax policies could impact the profitability of BHP’s operations. While Jakarta has stopped nickel exports, observers are looking at whether they will continue after Prabowo Subianto assumes the Indonesian presidency from Jokowi in October 2024, with Jokowi’s son, Gibran Rakabuming Raka as vice-president.
Environmental Concerns
Indonesia has faced criticism for its environmental management, particularly in the mining sector. BHP will need to ensure that its operations adhere to strict environmental standards to avoid reputational damage and potential conflicts with local communities.
Social Responsibility
Engaging with local communities and ensuring that they benefit from mining activities is crucial. BHP will need to develop robust community engagement strategies to build trust and support for its operations in Indonesia.
Conclusion
As Australian mining companies like BHP look to expand their operations into new foreign markets, they must carefully weigh the benefits against the risks. Setting up shop in another country offers opportunities for resource access, market diversification, and strategic partnerships. However, it also presents challenges related to regulatory compliance, political and economic risks, cultural differences, and environmental and social responsibilities.
BHP’s interest in the Indonesian nickel industry is a prime example of how an Australian mining company can strategically invest in a foreign base to secure its future growth. By navigating the complexities of the Indonesian market and building strong local partnerships, BHP can position itself as a key player in the global nickel supply chain while contributing to Indonesia’s economic development.
Ultimately, the success of any overseas expansion depends on thorough planning, risk management, and a commitment to sustainable and responsible mining practices. For Australian mining companies looking to venture overseas, the rewards can be significant, but only if they approach the opportunity with careful consideration and a long-term perspective.
DISCLAIMER: This article is for informational purposes only and does not supersede official business financial advice. AVANTE PARTNERS has no business interests with any mining company or government business offices in Australia and Indonesia. Please consult an international business law solicitor and financial advisor for your options.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COUNTRY
AVANTE PARTNERS acknowledges and pays respect to the past, present and future Traditional Custodians and Elders of this nation and the continuation of cultural, spiritual and educational practices of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.
